We all have habits - some good, some bad. While good habits can help us be more productive, healthy and successful, bad habits can hold us back and prevent us from reaching our full potential. If you've been struggling to break a bad habit, whether it's procrastination, overeating, smoking or something else, you're not alone. The good news is, there's a proven framework that can help you break those stubborn bad habits for good. It's called the Breaking Habits framework.
What is the Breaking Habits Framework?
The Breaking Habits framework is a step-by-step approach to breaking bad habits developed by James Clear, author of the bestselling book Atomic Habits. The framework is based on the science of habit formation and draws on insights from psychology, neuroscience and behavioral economics.
At its core, the Breaking Habits framework recognizes that habits are automatic behaviors that are triggered by cues in our environment. To break a bad habit, we need to identify and change those cues, make the habit less attractive and harder to do, and replace it with a healthier alternative. By following the steps in the framework, you can systematically break down and eliminate even the most deeply ingrained bad habits.
The 4 Laws of Behavior Change
The Breaking Habits framework is built around what Clear calls the "4 Laws of Behavior Change":
- Make it obvious
- Make it attractive
- Make it easy
- Make it satisfying
To break a bad habit, we need to invert these laws:
- Make it invisible
- Make it unattractive
- Make it difficult
- Make it unsatisfying
Let's look at each of these steps in more detail and how you can apply them to break your own bad habits.
Step 1: Make it Invisible
The first step to breaking a bad habit is to identify the cues that trigger the unwanted behavior. Cues can be anything in your environment - a certain time of day, a particular location, the presence of certain people, a feeling or emotion, etc. Once you've identified the cues, you need to make them invisible.
For example, let's say you have a habit of mindlessly snacking while watching TV at night. The cues might be sitting on the couch, turning on the TV, feeling bored or stressed. To make those cues invisible, you could:
- Rearrange your living room so the couch doesn't face the TV
- Remove unhealthy snacks from your house or hide them out of sight
- Find an alternative relaxing activity to do in the evenings like reading, crafts, etc.
- Plan ahead and portion out healthy snacks if you do want to eat something
By making the cues that prompt your bad habit invisible, you make it much less likely that you'll automatically fall into the old behavior pattern.
Step 2: Make it Unattractive
The second law of behavior change is to make the habit attractive. To break a bad habit, we need to do the opposite - make it unattractive.
One effective way to do this is to highlight the negative consequences of the unwanted behavior. Continuing with the snacking example, you could:
- Calculate how much money you're wasting on junk food each month
- Think about how the extra calories are affecting your health and weight
- Consider how you feel sluggish and unproductive after overeating unhealthy foods
- Visualize the long-term impacts like chronic diseases
You can also try reframing the unwanted behavior in a negative light. Instead of thinking "I deserve a treat after a long day", tell yourself "Corporations are exploiting my exhaustion to make me buy junk I don't need." The more unappealing and less desirable you can make the habit, the easier it will be to give it up.
Step 3: Make it Difficult
The next step is to put barriers in place that make it harder to do the unwanted behavior. The key is to add enough friction so that the bad habit isn't the automatic default.
For the snacking habit, you could:
- Stop buying junk food and keeping it in the house altogether
- Put any treats in hard-to-reach places like the back of the pantry
- Prep healthy snacks in advance so they're easy to grab
- Wear a rubber band on your wrist and snap it whenever you feel the urge to snack mindlessly
- Log your food intake to stay accountable
The more you can interrupt the behavior pattern and make the unwanted habit inconvenient to do, the less likely you are to do it. When friction is high, motivation to continue the bad habit wanes.
Step 4: Make it Unsatisfying
Finally, you want to make doing the bad habit unsatisfying. One way to do this is to use a habit contract. This is where you make the costs of your bad habits public and painful.
For example, you could tell your partner or a friend that every time they catch you mindlessly snacking, you'll pay them $5 or do one of their chores. Or post on social media that you'll donate $20 to a cause you hate if you fail to meet your goal. Knowing there is an immediate cost makes it much less satisfying to continue the bad behavior.
You can also find ways to reward yourself for avoiding the bad habit. For every night you successfully avoid snacking, put aside $5 for something you want. Or allow yourself to watch an episode of a favorite show only if you don't snack. Positive reinforcement for good behavior can be just as powerful as negative consequences.
Replacing Bad Habits with Good Ones
Quitting a bad habit is hard, but it's even harder when you try to just stop a behavior without replacing it with something else. Nature abhors a vacuum, as they say.
That's why an important part of the Breaking Habits framework is identifying a new, healthier habit you can do instead of the unwanted behavior. The new habit should meet the same need or provide the same reward as the bad habit.
In our snacking example, mindless eating often fulfills a need for stress relief, distraction or comfort. So instead of trying to just stop snacking, you could replace it with things like:
- Sipping herbal tea
- Doing a quick meditation
- Calling a friend for a chat
- Taking a short walk
- Journaling about your day
The key is to make the new habit obvious, attractive, easy and satisfying to do. Follow the 4 Laws of Behavior Change, but in the positive direction. Over time, the new routine will become the default habit.
Using Journaling to Break Bad Habits
One powerful tool that can support your habit change efforts is journaling. By taking a few minutes each day to write about your experiences, you gain valuable self-awareness and insight that enhances the Breaking Habits process.
Here are some journaling prompts to use:
- What bad habit do I want to break and why? Clearly identify the unwanted behavior and connect to your deeper motivation for change.
- What are the cues that trigger my bad habit? When, where and with whom am I most likely to do the behavior? How can I remove or avoid those cues?
- What are the negative consequences of my bad habit? How will my life be better when I no longer have this habit?
- What barriers can I put in place to make the bad habit harder to do? How can I add friction to the behavior?
- How will I make continuing the bad habit unsatisfying? What costs or accountability measures can I put in place?
- What new healthy habit could I do instead of the bad habit? How can I make this new routine attractive and easy to do?
- How did I do with my habit change today? What worked well? What challenges did I face? What do I want to focus on tomorrow?
The daily practice of reflection keeps your commitment to change front of mind. You'll start to notice patterns and be able to make small tweaks that add up to big shifts over time. Journaling also lets you celebrate your wins along the way, which is key to staying motivated in the long run.
Breaking Bad Habits Takes Time
It's important to remember that breaking deeply ingrained bad habits is a process. You didn't develop the unwanted behavior overnight, so it's unrealistic to think you can change it instantly.
Most experts agree it takes at least 2 months of consistent effort to break a bad habit for good. So it's crucial to be patient and kind with yourself. You will have setbacks and off days - that's totally normal. The key is to get back on track as quickly as possible and keep moving forward.
Using the Breaking Habits framework, you now have a clear, proven roadmap to finally kicking those bad habits that have held you back for too long. By identifying your cues, making the unwanted behavior invisible, unattractive and hard to do, and replacing it with a healthier alternative, you'll be well on your way to lasting habit change.
Journaling is a powerful way to support your efforts, gain self-awareness and stay accountable. With time, repetition and self-compassion, you can transform your habits and your life. The Breaking Habits framework shows you how - now it's up to you to put it into action!
Sources [1] Unlocking the Power of Habit: Cue, Routine, Reward Explained https://www.bookey.app/topic/unlocking-the-power-of-habit:-cue,-routine,-reward-explained [2] Groundhog Ways: Breaking Out of Your Habit Loop - Greatist https://greatist.com/happiness/habit-loop [3] The 5 Triggers That Make New Habits Stick - James Clear https://jamesclear.com/habit-triggers [4] A Practical Framework to Create and Break Habits - Roxana Murariu https://www.roxanamurariu.com/a-practical-framework-to-create-and-break-habits/ [5] Intentional Habit Tracking - Bullet Journal https://bulletjournal.com/blogs/bulletjournalist/intentional-habit-tracking [6] 4 Steps to Change a Habit - Habitbetter https://habitbetter.com/change-a-habit/ [7] How to Build a Journaling Habit that Lasts https://dayoneapp.com/blog/journaling-habit/ [8] 2 frameworks for changing bad habits (Part I) - Transitioning Your Life https://www.transitioningyourlife.com/2-frameworks-changing-bad-habits/ [9] Habits Guide: How to Build Good Habits and Break Bad Ones https://jamesclear.com/habits [10] The Role Of Accountability In Forming New Habits - Sarah Doody https://www.sarahdoody.com/the-role-of-accountability-in-forming-new-habits/ [11] The 1% Revolution: How to Make Habit Journaling a Habit https://www.intelligentchange.com/blogs/read/the-1-revolution-how-to-make-habit-journaling-a-habit [12] 12 Accountability Tricks To Help You Break That Bad Habit - Forbes https://www.forbes.com/sites/forbescoachescouncil/2017/06/28/13-accountability-tricks-to-help-you-break-that-bad-habit/?sh=6f640cab2ef0 [13] The Habit Reframe [METHOD] - updated. A completely different ... https://www.reddit.com/r/getdisciplined/comments/j7d5mm/the_habit_reframe_method_updated_a_completely/ [14] How To Break Bad Habits - The Ultimate Guide | JournalSmarter https://journalsmarter.com/how-to-break-bad-habits [15] How To Start New Habits That Actually Stick - James Clear https://jamesclear.com/three-steps-habit-change [16] Demonstrating and disrupting well-learned habits - PMC - NCBI https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC7292414/ [17] Atomic Habits By James Clear - Removing the cue when destroying ... https://www.reddit.com/r/productivity/comments/peif5m/atomic_habits_by_james_clear_removing_the_cue/ [18] The Science of Habit: How to Rewire Your Brain - Healthline https://www.healthline.com/health/the-science-of-habit [19] A framework for creating better habits and removing bad ones https://www.thefoundrychicago.com/a-framework-for-creating-better-habits-and-removing-bad-ones/ [20] How Daily Journaling and Reflection Can Boost Your Accountability ... https://www.rocky.ai/post/accountability-and-personal-growth